DEIA Series
 

The DEIA Rollback

How to preserve firm offerings despite mounting pressure to dissolve them.

By Kelly F. Zimmerman
July 2026
 

It’s been more than a year since the legal industry’s DEI initiatives came under fire on a national scale. In a matter of months, well-developed inclusion frameworks went from being key selling points for prospective clients and future employees to liabilities. The result: a scrubbing of DEI-related language from public-facing law firm communications.

Untitled Document

What firms once celebrated as a commitment to a diverse workforce with equitable opportunities has been met with pushback by the federal government and state-based jurisdictions alike. But that doesn’t mean the efforts have to be lost — and some organizations are signaling exactly that behind the scenes.

According to a 2026 survey of more than 2,200 employees in medium and large organizations, efforts to remove DEI appear more visible from the outside than what’s actually happening internally. The report, conducted by Catalyst, a women’s advancement nonprofit, and New York University Law, revealed that 55% of employees worked for companies that “signaled a public retreat from inclusion,” but only 34% said they actually reduced work in this area.

“What organizations say publicly about their inclusion initiatives doesn’t always tell the full story,” Christina Thomas, project director at the Meltzer Center for Diversity, Inclusion and Belonging at NYU Law, said in the press release. “Some of the disconnect is intentional: Organizations are responding to real legal and political pressure by changing their language and public posture. But the internal work is harder to undo. It’s embedded in people, processes and culture in ways that don’t shift as quickly as a public statement.”

While federal and state requirements continue to impact the way employers show up for employees — both internally and externally — inclusion doesn’t have to be a casualty of compliance. In fact, 80% of U.S. organizations surveyed by Catalyst and NYU remain committed to workplace inclusion efforts, a sign that workplaces aren’t abandoning their principles. They may, however, be evolving how they uphold them.

Embed Inclusion Efforts Across Firm Functions

Global DEI professional Marredia Crawford emphasizes the importance of integrating inclusion efforts across all functions of a firm rather than concentrating them within a single company initiative like hiring or recruitment. Embedding inclusion across firm efforts, from business development and practice group leadership to talent management and mentorship programs, helps ensure equitable access to professional development and growth opportunities throughout all areas of the organization.

Sometimes creating a more firm-wide accessible experience for colleagues can be as simple as meeting employee needs, such as providing captions in a global conference call setting or utilizing microphones and repeating questions in a crowded meeting room. “If we’re not impacting somebody’s day-to-day experience,” Crawford says, “we’ve already missed the mark.”

Build Cohort-Driven Programs

Due to ongoing political scrutiny surrounding DEI efforts that impact employees with protected characteristics, employers remain confused about the types of inclusive programming they can pursue. This is where cohort-driven programs present a viable solution. By creating mentorship programs or training with core competencies that apply to a particular cohort of attorneys or staff — for example, all third-year associates — your firm can provide valuable and equitable resources that provide everyone the same opportunity, Crawford says.

Embedding inclusion across firm efforts, from business development and practice group leadership to talent management and mentorship programs, helps ensure equitable access to professional development and growth opportunities throughout all areas of the organization.

Continue Compliance Audits

A June 2026 presentation hosted by the Illinois Human Rights Commission highlighted the importance of auditing internal programs and practices that may inadvertently limit membership or separate employees into groups based on defining and protected characteristics, such as race or sex. This can include initiatives like affinity or employee resource groups, fellowship or leadership programs, or even networking events — all integral parts of law firm and corporate culture. Understanding how to navigate these waters is especially critical during a time when law firms and private corporations have been targeted for certain workplace culture initiatives. But recent court challenges to these programs don’t mean they have to go.

The presentation noted that legal challenges targeting affinity groups and employee resource groups have failed in certain instances when these groups were open to all employees. It’s when participation has been limited by race, sex, or other protected characteristics that organizations have faced heightened legal exposure. This helps provide a roadmap for employers as they navigate this territory and consider their own affinity groups and employee resource groups.

In June 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission released an updated National Enforcement Plan prioritizing actions against organizations that categorize internal practices, programs or policies based on protected characteristics. This plan is currently slated to remain in place through fiscal year 2029.

As legal requirements and guidance continue to evolve at both the federal and state level, it’s important to continue reviewing existing programs and policies to ensure ongoing compliance. This is especially critical during a time when law firms have been singled out for certain workplace culture initiatives.

Search for and Address Unintended Barriers

Identifying and breaking down unintended barriers to resources and opportunities requires more than a basic policy audit. It requires listening, active engagement and creating space for collaboration. “If you’re not a part of a community,” Crawford says, “it may not cross your mind that [an initiative] is a barrier for someone else.”

Something as straightforward as expanding parental leave to include fathers, adoptive or surrogate parents, and same-sex couples can impact the employee experience at a firm-wide level, taking all experiences and family situations into account.

ABA President Michelle A. Behnke echoes this sentiment, acknowledging there is no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to addressing diversity issues. “One of the biggest obstacles firms face is just a lack of knowledge of what the potential barriers might be and engaging with those that face those barriers to find solutions,” Behnke says.

5 Ways to Put Inclusion into Practice

Regardless of how your firm has navigated the shifting landscape, these five practices offer a starting point for keeping inclusion efforts meaningful, consistent and defensible.

1. Keep Consistent Processes

Avoiding ambiguity in how you promote accessibility and inclusivity can help protect your firm in the long run, Crawford says. Maintaining clear, consistent policies that are formally documented can help demonstrate how decisions are made across the firm.

2. Show, Don’t Tell

Employees need to see that you still care about providing opportunities for ongoing development and accessibility. This requires active demonstration. Continue providing exposure to conferences, mentorship programs and client-facing opportunities to ensure all employees can develop new skill sets and strengthen business rapport.

3. Revisit Your Recruitment Tactics

Building a truly inclusive firm begins with the hiring process. Broadening recruitment and outreach efforts can meaningfully expand your applicant pool, but it’s also important to remove any friction from the process. Tactics to encourage fair hiring practices may include:

  • Accessible job postings that are free of exclusionary language
  • Standardized interview processes
  • Unconscious bias checks
  • Conducting pay equity audits

4. Continue Workplace Conduct Training

Creating not only a welcoming environment, but also a safe one, is critical to maintaining an inclusive workplace culture. Continuing to reinforce policies and training around respectful workplace conduct, including anti-bullying and anti-harassment measures, helps ensure every employee can do their best work without fear of retaliation or exclusion.

5. Consider Your Firm’s Scale

DEI solutions are not cookie-cutter, and compliance regulations may differ from one firm to the next, depending on location. For example, a small city-based practice may face different regulations than a large multistate organization that covers many jurisdictions. Multinational organizations with stronger DEI policies may also come into conflict with U.S. or state-based regulations. Regardless of size or geography, understanding your firm’s compliance requirements is the first step toward building an inclusion strategy that’s both meaningful and defensible.

Standing Firm While Remaining Compliant

The legal industry was made to deal with ongoing complexity. Navigating competing regulations, evolving precedents and high-stakes decisions is the basis of what law firms do on the daily — whether that involves dealing with a client matter or revisiting DEI initiatives.

The firms that find a sustainable path forward will be the ones that continue to refine their processes, listen to their employees and build a culture rooted in genuine commitment rather than external pressure.

Also in This Issue

Back to Top