With one-in-four graduates beginning their legal career in Big Law, the competition is fierce – not only for graduating law students to get in, but for law firms competing for the best talent, whether or not they have the budget to show for it. However, even if the majority of firms aren’t able to compete dollar for dollar, there are other ways for them to compete on their own terms. Let’s explore how.
Be Strategic About Salary
Matching the largest salaries on the legal market does not have to be synonymous with remaining competitive when it comes to recruitment. Instead of trying to keep up with the terms of other firms, Zaretsky recommends focusing on targeted raises and meaningful bonuses to help retain the lawyers whose departure would hurt the firm most.
“Keeping up doesn’t necessarily mean matching every raise,” Zaretsky says. “It means knowing what the market is paying and making sure your compensation doesn’t give your best lawyers a reason to take a call from a recruiter.”
Even if the majority of firms aren’t able to compete dollar for dollar, there are other ways for them to compete on their own terms.
John Jakovenko, CLM, SPHR, a fractional chief operating officer, recommends focusing on a pay model that emphasizes the rule of thirds as a way for smaller firms to remain competitive. Under this model, the law firm takes their billable hour rate and multiplies it by the attorney’s required hours, then divides it into thirds: One-third goes to the firm, one-third goes toward profits and the last third is for the attorney. Essentially it looks like this:
| Breakdown of Salary Model | Example |
| Billable hour rate x Required hours = A | $250 x 1,800 = $450,000 |
| A ÷ 3 = B | $450,000 ÷ 3 = $150,000 |
| B = Attorney salary | $150,000 |
Another way to approach this is by offering a base salary and then incorporating the one-thirds model as a bonus, offering one-third of collected hours after they reach their required billable hours. With this model, the more an attorney bills and collects, the more they can earn.
| Breakdown of Bonus Model | Example |
| Base salary = A | $150,000 |
| Billable hour requirement = B | 1,800 |
| Billable hour rate = C | $250 |
| C x Extra hours collected = D | $250 x 100 = 25,000 |
| A + D | $150,000 + $25,000 = $175,000 |
If attorneys are still looking for additional compensation after that, you can get creative by raising the billable hour requirement or even offering a percentage of originations they bring in.
“Ultimately, they can get unlimited money, depending on how efficient they are and how much they can bill,” Jakovenko says. “It gets them to where they want to be. They just have to trust in the process and trust in their skillset. It’s breakeven for everybody.”
Some firms choose to get creative by offering lower salaries up front but then dispersing more during bonus time. This allows the firm to collect a bigger profit at the start with a larger payout on the backend. However, this model may not be for everyone.
Get Creative with Your Benefits
Any company can say they offer competitive benefits and flexibility, but paying attention to what’s important to them can help guide a firm’s total reward package.
Lowenstein Sandler, a law firm with over 400 lawyers, demonstrated this by recently expanding their paid parental leave to include extra paid time off for parents whose newborns require an extended stay in a neonatal intensive care unit (NICU). The policy includes up to eight weeks of additional paid time off under these circumstances.
In order to stand out, it has to go beyond basic PTO and flexible schedules.
“If you want to show your associates that you value them as more than a billable hour producer and as a human, you can empathize with their lives,” Zaretsky says. “Having a benefit like that is something that will show your employees that you truly do actually care about them and not just what they can do as their work product.”
Fenwick & West is another firm touting some interesting vacation perks, which Zaretsky wrote about in Above the Law. The firm offers a “Rest, Relaxation, and Recreation” (“Triple R”) rewards and Firm Condo program for attorneys who “exceed associate expectations and make significant contributions to the firm.”
From childcare assistance to gym memberships and even concierge assistants, there are a number of ways that firms can incorporate benefits to help attorneys work hard while also prioritizing their families and well-being. But in order to stand out, it has to go beyond basic PTO and flexible schedules.
“Smaller and midsize firms need to stay competitive not just on pay, but on the lifestyle benefits that they’re essentially selling to their employees,” Zaretsky says.
Give Access to Clients Early and Often
NALP Foundation’s 2025 Update on Associate Attrition reports a record-breaking 83% of associates who departed in 2025 left their firms within five years of hire. This is a 3% increase from the year prior and signals a serious attrition problem for law firms.
Providing a realistic path to advancement is key to remaining competitive with other firms and giving your attorneys a reason to stay. This applies to both recruitment and retention.
“Give them opportunities in court instead of just doing document review,” Zaretsky says. “Let them [be] second chair. Let them come to a client meeting and actually have an opportunity to speak.” Providing access to clients, she says, is the best way to learn.
Boast about Billing
When a firm raises its billing rates beyond what a partner’s clients can afford, the partner’s realization rate can drop, impacting their ability to grow and maintain their book of business. Not only is this not good for the firm, but it’s not good for the attorney and can lead to them rethinking where they practice.
Talent acquisition executive Tamara Klein has seen this firsthand. She has moved candidates who were priced out of their market “just a little bit downstream” to firms that bill slightly less but still compete on reputation and quality of work. The lower rates made it easier for those attorneys to hold on to clients throughout their lateral move and build their book of business.
Compensation was only seventh on the list of considerations leading new associates to choose their firm. Factors like culture, reputation, caliber of people and client/work quality outranked it.
That’s where smaller firms can have an edge. A firm that can’t meet Big Law salaries but has attorneys of the same caliber billing at a lower rate has a huge advantage in earning new business, Klein says. This can be a talking point during recruitment conversations, particularly for lateral hires looking for career growth.
This strategy applies not only to partners, but to associates as well. As Klein puts it, they’re asking: “How feasible is it that I'm going to make partner? And when I make partner, how feasible is it that I'm going to be able to develop my own book of business?” This can be easier for lawyers to do if they’re at a firm with “the same skillset and representation but bills out at a lower rate.”
A 2026 report from legal research firm Chambers found that salary benchmarking, flexible work policies and well-being programs are not the “primary drivers of motivation or flight risk” for associates. Using responses from 8,200 associates across 82 U.S. firms, the report found that compensation was only seventh on the list of considerations leading new associates to choose their firm. Factors like culture, reputation, caliber of people and client/work quality outranked it.
This makes sense based on Klein’s perspective that aligning values is just as important as aligning on compensation. “You’ve got to figure out what the internal driving force of a firm is and what the candidate's internal driving force is,” she says. Not only will this lead to a stronger recruitment process, but it will help with retention, as well.