He warns that a firm can become seriously weakened "if law firm owners don’t begin to transition parts of their firm to the next generation" well in advance of their retirement, with the uncertainty causing top talent to find a more secure future elsewhere and often posing difficulty in attracting the strongest candidates to replace them.
Challenges of Discussing Succession Planning with Senior Partners
Raising the prospect of retirement or departure of senior partners can be quite a sensitive issue and may lead to defensiveness if not handled delicately. According to Woodward, a discussion about succession planning, if not handled well, can result in a key partner feeling "they are compromising their own position and giving away the relationships which they have spent decades cultivating. That can lead to a person becoming disengaged and, potentially, push them to leave the firm and take their client relationships with them."
As such, legal administrators should ensure that any conversations are managed carefully, taking into account the circumstances of each individual partner alongside any particular sensitivities they may have.
There are multiple dynamics at play in many firms, especially when overall management is in the hands of founding partners. Hawkins says that in founder-led firms, "the senior partners have trouble letting go of their baby ... many senior partners' identities are wrapped up in being a lawyer, and they cannot imagine doing anything else. Many older lawyers enjoy practicing law and don't want to stop."
The absence of a succession plan is not only a problem at the time of transition — it can start to bite months or years in advance.
However, Hawkins notes that the reverse can also be true: "On the flip side, I've had many discussions with law firm owners who want to transition their firm, but their junior lawyers have no interest in taking over the firm."
How Can Legal Administrators Broach the Topic Diplomatically and Effectively?
By highlighting the practical issues concerning the departure of a key partner — such as operational continuity and securing ongoing financing — legal administrators can reduce the emotional aspects associated with the topic of succession planning. Formalizing processes and decentralizing decision-making where appropriate can help avoid complications arising from personal sentiments and move things onto a business footing.
Hawkins argues that the "stronger a firm's operations team is, the more likely the firm will successfully transition to the next generation. Legal administrators should push senior leaders to invest in and professionalize their firm’s operations as much as possible. That will not only make succession planning more likely, but it will likely improve the profitability of the firm in the here and now."
It's also vital that transition plans pertaining to the departure of key partners are considered as far in advance as possible.
Woodward says that, in order to be successful, succession planning "should be a process which starts significantly before the point of exit. Standard elements of this involve adding additional points of contact, spending time socializing the firm’s wider team, and ensuring the soft knowledge about a client’s preferences and processes is held as institutional information. The earlier this is all put in place, the better for the law firm."
The Impact of Firm Size and Generational Shifts
According to Hawkins, the approach to succession planning in small firms is often quite different from larger outfits: "In smaller firms, the options are more limited because there are fewer potential lawyer successors in the firm, and if the lawyers that are there have no interest in taking over the firm, then the options are typically to shut the firm down or merge it into another firm." In comparison, he says that larger practices "typically have more rainmakers and more potential successor lawyers" as well as more administrative support, all of which makes transitions easier.
Formalizing processes and decentralizing decision-making where appropriate can help avoid complications arising from personal sentiments and move things onto a business footing.
Aside from the size and departmental resources available to a firm, shifting attitudes to succession planning among different generations of lawyers can also contribute to its ability to weather the departure of key partners. Hawkins says that, whereas in previous generations "it was expected that lawyers would work up the ranks to become equity owners and take over the firm," in recent years he has noticed an increasing number of younger lawyers with "no interest in owning equity, taking over leadership roles or assisting in administrative duties."
Planning for the Future
In addition to all the traditional challenges of succession planning explored above, the rise of AI adds further uncertainties about the future of the legal profession into the mix. It's therefore even more critical that law firms are on top of the more predictable future possibilities, so they are better placed to tackle some of the more unknown impacts of a fast-evolving world.
Talking to partners about succession planning can be difficult, especially if it touches upon emotionally charged subjects such as aging and mortality, but many of the emerging discussions about the future of the billable hour, implications of AI and prioritization of DEIA are even trickier. By starting with a robust succession planning process, legal administrators can ensure their firm is ready to tackle everything coming up ahead.